THE OVERLAND
TELEGRAPH LINE
A TRANSCULTURAL HISTORY
When the Overland Telegraph Line was completed on 22 August 1872, it activated a communication wire across the Australian continent, from Adelaide to Port Darwin, that connected the Australian colonies to each other, to the rest of the British Empire and to the world. Understandably, it is often described as the greatest feat of engineering in colonial Australia. Overseen by Superintendent of Telegraphs Charles Todd, the Overland Telegraph Line was built in three sections – southern, central and northern - between 1870 and 1872.
It did not create the first line of communication through the continent’s interior: Aboriginal pathways of communication, trade and exchange had criss-crossed the continent for millennia. But it did facilitate a European overland route of access across the country that became a catalyst for further colonisation, cross-cultural encounter and the formation of new kinds of relationships.
In October 1872, the Adelaide Telegraph Office received the first message of the newly opened Overland Telegraph Line. This was the culmination of some two and a half years of construction which involved an immense commitment of resources and labour. The Overland Telegraph Line’s construction is often remembered for its technical difficulties and technological achievement, but the line also brought social, cultural and environmental upheaval for the many Aboriginal groups whose lands it passed through. Charles Todd’s instructions to overseers in charge of works stressed that the construction parties should avoid contact with Aboriginal people. But contact inevitably occurred and on both sides it produced a mix of curiosity, concern and conflict.
PART ONE
STUART'S JOURNEY
The Overland Telegraph Line followed the route taken by the explorer John McDouall Stuart, who between 1860 and 1862 led a series of expeditions that mapped and claimed a strip of country between the colonial outposts of Port Augusta and Port Darwin. Prior to these expeditions Stuart surveyed land leading north of Adelaide identifying places of interest. While making the return from the north represented the success of his endeavours, Stuart’s journey towards this success was an integral part of colonising Aboriginal Lands. His journals provide an insight into his intentions and his interactions. The sketches of Stephen King and account of George Waterhouse provide additional perspectives on the final journey of Stuart and his party.
King sketch of Stuart's expedition hoisting flag at north coast [SLSA B 486/31]
King sketch of Stuart's expedition hoisting flag at north coast [SLSA B 486/31]
As the first European to enter these areas, Stuart’s meticulous mapping was valuable. However, he was mapping land that had been known and connected to Aboriginal people for tens of thousands of years. After his earliest explorations Stuart used his journal and map as currency in exchange for Arabana Country from the South Australian government. His application emphasised the importance of his maps, and his request for a lease was granted. Arabana people were not consulted as the colonisers parcelled out their land.
The sponsorship he received from wealthy leaseholders enabled Stuart to explore further inland. James and John Chambers were particularly supportive along with William Finke. Through his mapping Stuart erased Aboriginal names of places, instead honouring those who were vital to his explorations. These maps and journals contained information that would enable his sponsors to determine how profitable the land might be for European land use. It was the key to claiming Aboriginal land and increasing their wealth.
It is a pillar of sandstone standing on a hill upwards of one hundred feet high…I have named it ‘Chambers Pillar’ in honour of James Chambers Esq., who, with William Finke Esq. has been my great supporter in all my explorations.
Stuart’s expeditions were not only a precursor to the Overland Telegraph line: they laid its foundation. While Stuart recorded the potential for mining and stock, he also recorded suitable places to build telegraph stations and established whether there was suitable timber for poles. During his final expedition while near Newcastle Waters he commented on the difficulties presented by the plains and scrub, but felt they could be overcome:
For a telegraphic communication I should think that three or four wells would overcome this difficulty and the want of water, and the forest could be penetrated by cutting a line through and burning it
As Stuart crossed numerous Aboriginal lands, his interactions with Aboriginal people varied. Stuart recognised that people responded with fear, shock, and intrigue when seeing his team on their horses. As an experienced explorer, Stuart entered these spaces with a method in mind, a method he had adopted from Charles Sturt. In 1844, Stuart had been a draughtsman on Sturt’s inland expedition and would have seen the way Sturt behaved when he came into contact with Aboriginal people. Sturt believed the best way was
"… not to alarm their natural timidity; to exercise patience in your intercourse with them; to treat them kindly; and to watch them with suspicion, especially at night. Never permit your men to steal away from camp, but keep them as compact as possible; and at every station arrange your drays and provisions that they may serve as a defence in case of your being attacked."
Stuart was also gifted a rifle by Richard MacDonnell, the governor of South Australia, who expressed the hope that he would not use it on a human being.
To traverse the continent without having to use [the weapons] against any human being ... The best proof of your courage is to be found in your judicious forbearance on so many previous occasions and your avoidance of all unnecessary collisions with the native heretofore.
Stuart routinely followed most of these instructions, but just as Aboriginal peoples’ responses varied, his reactions to their responses also changed.
The importance of waterways to Aboriginal people meant that rivers, creeks and soaks became places where they would come into contact with Stuart. Stuart was not particularly interested in Aboriginal cultures, but he used the knowledge of Aboriginal people to his own benefit. On 13 May 1859 he met some people in Arabana Country, south-west of Lake Eyre, who taught him some of their language. He noted similar words he had heard from Aboriginal people in the Barngarla and Nauo region, near Port Lincoln. While Stuart did not record the name of their language, he did record several words including the word mauwe. He understood mauwe to mean ‘water’, an incredibly important word he needed during his travels. Which language this word comes from is unclear, but it does have similarities with the word awi, meaning water in Adnyamathanha. As Stuart had worked and travelled in that region for many years he may have recalled it from that time.
Stuart’s need for water was exacerbated by the horses he relied on for transport. As he travelled, each step was taken towards the next available water source. He used Aboriginal people’s footprints and smoke as ways of finding water, knowing they were probably in close proximity to water. On 26 June 1859, not far from his previous interaction, Stuart met with some more people who were most likely Arabana. He asked them where he could locate water. They showed him where to get water and Stuart allowed his horses to drink. The horses completely emptied the well, prompting Stuart to ask for another location. They let Stuart know there was no more, likely concerned that the horses would leave nothing. It was not only Stuart’s presence in areas of water that were concerning for Aboriginal people; his horses could take all remaining water, making them dangerous.
Stuart placed himself near water sources nightly, at times scaring people away from their camps so that he was closer to water sources. On the 17 December 1859 he came towards a creek near Mount Margaret that had Aboriginal people camped in it. When they saw him they ran away, climbed atop a cliff and yelled repeatedly at Stuart to leave. Stuart persisted, camping and staying there that night. When he awoke he noticed acacia seeds, and realised that his party had camped where the people he had scared away had been preparing a large quantity of the important foodstuff. This one was of many occasions when Stuart ignored clear requests to leave.
Stuart felt the repercussions of his actions on 25 June 1860 at a place he would soon rename Attack Creek, in the Northern Territory. He had his men set up camp near a place he earlier saw was occupied by a group of Aboriginal people we would eventually come to know as the Warumungu. Seeing no fires or smoke he believed they had left. Later that night Stuart felt the full extent of Warumungu resistance as over 30 warriors stood against Stuart. The Warumungu were fighting against Stuart as he accessed their water without asking for permission. The men lit fires, threw boomerangs and sent the party repeated requests to leave. They moved in ways that Stuart felt were cleverly orchestrated. Stuart ordered his men to shoot towards the resistance and eventually fled. Fearful that he would have similar experiences, he abandoned the expedition and returned to Adelaide.
They are not to be trusted: they will pretend the greatest friendship one moment and spear you the next. They have been following us to-day, but keeping on the other side of the river and setting fire to the grass as they go along. I wish it would rain and cause the grass to become green, so as to stop them burning
While Aboriginal people were important in locating water, they eventually became obstacles to Stuart’s mission. His actions were influencing how Aboriginal people reacted to his presence. Water scarcity would have been an issue, but Stuart would have also received warnings for trespassing on sacred and restricted areas. Stuart did not need to understand Aboriginal cultures to know he was not welcome in these areas; he mentions multiple times in his journals that he was told to leave- and yet he persisted in ignoring these warnings. How Stuart viewed Aboriginal people started to change, with little self-reflection on how his presence had become detrimental to their survival and way of living.
If they do [attack] I shall be compelled to use preventive means with them, for I can stand it no longer; they must be taught a lesson that we possess a little more power than they anticipate.
Stuart began his expeditions with a reluctance to use his rifle, but on his final expedition he began to use it as a show of power. He regularly used his rifle to shoot, even when he was not at risk.
""I had the party prepared to receive an attack; but when they saw us stationary they approached no nearer. I ordered some of the party to fire close to them, to show them we could injure them at a long distance, if they continued to annoy us, but they did not seem at all frightened at the report of the rifles nor the whizzing of the balls near to them, since they still remained in a threatening attitude.
Stuart’s navigational skills and the records he produced provide important information that paved the way for the Overland Telegraph Line, a legacy remembered today. However, the legacy he left for many Aboriginal people was quite different, and this was something he was aware of. When Stuart returned to an area near Attack Creek he recorded the following interaction:
"Taking out a small strip of white calico which he had in his pocket, he tore it into two and held it out to them. They wished to possess it, but did not fancy coming too close to him for it. He made a sign that he wished to tie it round their wrists; they gradually approached nearer, holding out their arms at full length, and so frightened were they to come close, that he had to reach out his full length to tie them on; after which they gained a little more confidence, pointed towards the gun, imitated the report with their mouth, and held up three fingers, signifying that they recollected my first visit and number, which they do not seem to have forgotten, and seem to dread the appearance of a gun.
Following Stuart’s successful crossing of the continent, South Australia pressed its claim to the country between its northern boundary and the coast, and in July 1863 the Northern Territory was annexed to South Australia. South Australia then succeeded in securing the route for the Overland Telegraph Line. Constructed largely along Stuart’s route, it made Adelaide the hub of a communications network connecting the Australian colonies with the rest of the British Empire and Europe.
The world changed irrevocably for the Aboriginal people whose country Stuart had passed through, as the repeater stations became outposts of European colonisation, and pastoral stations, townships and mining settlements spread outwards from the line.
PART TWO
THE SOUTHERN SECTION
The southern section of the Overhead Telegraph Line followed the pastoral corridor north, expanding the existing path of colonial occupation. As the construction parties moved along the Line’s planned route, they crossed the boundaries of country occupied, managed and intimately known by Aboriginal people for millennia. Jurisprudence scholar Christine Black writes that Aboriginal people’s rights and responsibilities have always been structured as a relationship between law and country, and country in turn binds people to lawful conduct. Lawful conduct meant negotiating permission to enter another’s country, something rarely undertaken by European parties.
B. Herschel Babbage, sketch of the Overland Telegraph Line route, Beltana Station paddock and trig, c. 1871 [SLSA PRG 404/19/3/71]
B. Herschel Babbage, sketch of the Overland Telegraph Line route, Beltana Station paddock and trig, c. 1871 [SLSA PRG 404/19/3/71]
The contract for the Southern Section of the Overland Telegraph Line was awarded to Edward Bagot, a stock and station agent, who had a direct interest in locating pastoral land in Central Australia. The contract entailed erecting and wiring about twenty telegraph poles each mile, for 500 miles (800 kilometres), from Strangways Springs to the Peake (both of which operated as both pastoral stations and repeater stations), across Arabana and Arrernte country.
The system of contracting out work for the Line’s three sections generated occasional protest, partly in recognition of the risks posed by passing through country without establishing good relations with the Aboriginal owners. In July 1870, for example, a correspondent wrote to the Adelaide Express and Telegraph demanding that the government rather than private contractors undertake the work: ‘A body of men are to be sent into an unknown country, under the tender care of contractors, whose only aim will be to make as much profit out of the thing as possible ….this work is one of friendly relations with the natives, through which the line will pass, or one of unending enmity’(6 July 1870). But while the government did take management of the Central Section, the Southern Section was left to Bagot, who afterwards took up the lease of Undoolya station on Central Arrernte country and became one of the most active land-holders and speculators in northern South Australia.
The journals kept by the men of the Telegraph Line construction parties often recorded an impression of setting foot in untrodden lands, and relayed their first encounters with Aboriginal people from that perspective.
The River is about 8 chains in width with sharp banks but we managed to get down all right and crossed the river … from the top of the hill we had a splendid view of the country there is a long plane [sic] on the other side as far as the eye can reach.
But observing the Line’s construction parties from their own country, Aboriginal people would have been alert to the intruders’ approach. As historian Henry Reynolds writes, they were likely already ‘armed with knowledge and expectations’ about these incomers from neighbouring groups, and ready to respond with caution, curiosity or defiance.
The first repeater station north of Port Augusta was established on the lands of Kuyani people, close neighbours to Adnyamathanha people to the east. Its chosen site was the Beltana pastoral station, acquired by the pastoralist and politician Thomas Elder in 1862. Well before the construction of the Overland Telegraph Line, pastoral possession of precious water and land resources, combined with drought, placed enormous pressure on Kuyani and Andyamathanha people. In 1867 the Sub-Protector of Aborigines for the Far North, John Parker Buttfield, reported on sickness and hunger among Aboriginal people caused by the ‘almost total absence of native animals, and the failure of other resources’. The Overland Telegraph Line added to these pressures by opening a path for further pastoral expansion.
In the mid-1860s, Beltana became the first station to use camels for the transport of pastoral supplies when Thomas Elder and fellow pastoralist Samuel Stuckey imported a herd of camels and a team of cameleers from what is now Pakistan. Commonly referred to as ‘ships of the desert’, camels proved very effective for the transportation of goods and supplies in the dry interior. When the Overland Telegraph Line was erected in the early 1870s, camels and ‘Afghan’ cameleers were employed to carry the necessary supplies to the inland construction camps.
Typically referred to simply as ‘Afghans’, cameleers came not only from what is now Afghanistan but from various provinces of what was then part of the north-western British Indian Empire. Usually employed on indenture contracts of two or three years, their labour was sought because of their specialised skills in inland cartage work that Europeans were ill-equipped to perform. Also unlike European workers, cameleers’ indenture contracts included a minimum monthly wage supplemented with rations. The cameleers were in demand for their unique skill set, and there is evidence that their work was valued. Predominantly Muslim, they were also frequently subject to European suspicion and discrimination.
Many of the cameleers contracted from what is now Afghanistan, Pakistan and northwest India returned to their homelands when their indenture contracts expired. But others remained, married Aboriginal or European wives, and built permanent livelihoods in the townships that developed around the telegraph stations and railheads. The cameleers established Australia’s first mosques and the foundations of Australia’s early Muslim communities.
Repeater and pastoral stations along the Overland Telegraph Line became the departure point for other overland expeditions east and west of the line. While exploration expeditions are typically known by the names of their European leaders, their success depended upon the skills and knowledge of Aboriginal guides and Afghan cameleers. Alfred Gile's 1875 expedition across the Great Victoria Desert followed two earlier attempts to cross the western desert. It left from the Beltana pastoral and telegraph station supported by camels supplied by Thomas Elder. The party included two Aboriginal guides, including the young Wirangu man Tommy Oldham, and the Afghan cameleer Mahomet Saleh, who was already an experienced expeditioner.
Cameleer labour was indispensable to the construction of both the Overland Telegraph Line and the transcontinental railway line, which began construction in 1878, following the Overland Telegraph Line’s route. In 1883, the Afghan brothers Faiz and Tagh Mahomet established their own successful camel cartage company at the new railhead township of Maree (formerly Hergott Springs), halfway between the Beltana and Strangways Springs Telegraph Stations in Kuyani country. As well as servicing most of the new supply routes through Central Australia, the Mahomet brothers held a contract with the Superintendent of Telegraphs, Charles Todd, to deliver telegraph stores and equipment to the Telegraph Line stations.
Maree (Hergott Springs), the railhead town between Beltana and Strangways Springs Telegraph Stations, developed as a vibrant transcultural town. Today descendants of the Muslim cameleers still hold an important place in the trans-cultural heritage of Indigenous Australia.
The Strangways Springs Telegraph Station was established in Arabana country and, like Beltana, at the site of an existing pastoral station. Like their neighbours to the south, Arabana people had endured the combined impacts of pastoralism and drought by 1871 when the Overland Telegraph Line came through. By this time, the South Australian colonial government had established a network of rations depots through the colony’s northern districts (and elsewhere) to alleviate the impacts of colonisation and drought on Aboriginal communities. Providing quarterly issues of flour, sugar, tea and other minimum necessities, rations depots in the north were usually located at police stations, pastoral stations and telegraph repeater stations. Like other pastoral and repeater stations in the north, the Strangways Springs station played a complex role as a site of colonial dispossession, a rations depot and an Aboriginal gathering place.
The pastoral industry was hit with a major labour shortage during the 1850s as European workers disappeared to the Victorian goldfields, and Aboriginal men and women began replacing European workers as shearers, wool-sorters, stockmen and women, boundary riders, fence-builders and domestic workers. Pastoral employers usually paid their Aboriginal workforce not in wages but in the government-supplied rations that were commonly distributed from pastoral, telegraph and police stations. This marked a shift from an aggressive phase of Aboriginal dispossession to an unwaged labour relationship.
Aboriginal people’s experience in the pastoral industry varied widely, but their essential contribution to the pastoral industry meant many people remained on their countries. The Australian historian Ann McGrath describes the relationship between pastoralists and Aboriginal workers as a kind of symbiosis. Even as the labour relationship continued an ‘unjust social order’, she writes, pastoralists were ‘aware that that in many ways the country remained Aboriginal’. In 1899, John Hogarth at Strangways Springs was one of numerous pastoralists who testified to a government Select Committee on the vital role of Aboriginal people in the pastoral industry.
PART THREE
THE CENTRAL SECTION
The 1870-81 northern reconnaissance party for the Line under John Ross encountered Stuart's challenge in locating suitable passes or 'gaps' through the MacDonnell Range or Tjoritja. The range fell within the western part of Arrernte country, a vast expanse of central Australia encompassing approximately 150,000 square kilometres of land and incorporating multiple associated languages. The problem was compounded by the Europeans’ own trespass on Aboriginal country; the general principle of seeking permission for access did not occur to Stuart, or to others at that time. At least two collisions occurred - one in which perhaps several Arrernte died, in a battle of spears against rifles, and another threatened skirmish as the party made its way north through the Ranges, via the waterhole Turtiara, which Ross named Alice Springs for Todd's wife.
This watercolour was painted by the surveyor J.B. Harvey, who accompanied John Ross’s reconnaissance expedition of 1870. At Charles Todd’s direction, Ross was seeking a viable route for the Overland Telegraph Line through the MacDonnell Ranges and a site for a telegraph station. The image shows Ross’s party of five men and their team of pack horses and spare mounts, unaware of the armed Arrernte party, poised to attack.
Thomas Frederick Smith worked on the southern and central sections of the Overland Telegraph Line and his diary records sightings of Aboriginal groups from a distance and occasional brief encounters. As his party passed through Arrernte country, in sight of the MacDonnell Ranges, Smith noted that Aboriginal people were ‘very numerous’. Sometimes Arrernte parties followed the incomers but ‘don’t show themselves’ (11 January 1871). At other times they ‘waved to us to clear out’ (12 April 1871). On the whole, he thought, they didn’t welcome the presence of the Europeans but showed diplomatic forbearance towards them. Other construction parties reported that Aboriginal people ‘shake their spears in token of defiance’ (10 June 1871).
In April 1871, heavy rainfall flooded watercourses in Arrernte country, washing away wire from the Overland Telegraph and stalling work at what would become the Alice Springs Telegraph Station. The South Australian Register reported on 18 April 1872 that at Alice Springs ‘the grass has grown in abundance’, but Aboriginal people ‘keep out of sight’. No doubt, though, they observed the Europeans’ activity. The Alice Springs station layout was typical of the main repeater stations. The complex comprised the station-masters quarters, an office, men's hut, harness-room, transport store, blacksmith's shop and cart-shed, together with stockyard and well. The buildings have survived intact until the present day. The Arrernte camped close to the station, establishing a semi-permanent camp there from the 1870s until the 1920s.
During his 1875 journey to his first introductory posting to the Alice Springs Telegraph Station, the young telegraphist Francis Gillen recorded two vocabularies from Aboriginal people, at the Peake station and at Charlotte Waters. Together, these comprise the first written records of Arabana, Wangkangurru and Lower Arrernte. Gillen would later work closely with Arrernte men and women at Alice Springs.
Superintendent of Telegraphs Charles Todd shared the dominant Victorian view of relentless British expansion, inevitably expanding and sweeping across indigenous landscapes, and there is no doubt that he gave little thought to the effects on Aboriginal people of his technological installation penetrating and crossing their countries. It is worth noting then, that Todd thought it important to gather a vocabulary of Arabana words at the Peake telegraph station.
The Telegraph Line as an exploration base
The Overland Telegraph Line served as a dividing line between ‘explored’ and ‘unexplored’ Australia. To the east the inland interior was becoming known to Europeans, but to the west lay the forbidding western deserts. With its well-supplied repeater stations, the Telegraph Line took on a new role as a base for exploration during the 1870s. Successful or not, those explorations brought a series of Aboriginal desert cultures into contact with Europeans.
By the late 1870s Europeans had learnt that the country to the west of the Line was unsuitable for pastoralism. It would be another sixty years or so before the western desert groups such as the Ngadadjara, Pitjantjatjara, Pintubi and Warlpiri began leaving their ancient desert homelands for European settlements and missions.
During the 1870s several exploring expeditions attempted to cross the western deserts, either from the Telegraph Line or towards it, including Major Peter Egerton Warburton. Travelling by camel with Afghan cameleers, his party eventually reached the west coast, but were forced well northwards of their initial objective and almost perished in the attempt. As they struggled to reach the Western Australia coast the party survived only by eating their camels, and through the bush skills of their Aboriginal tracker, recorded only as ‘Charley’.
The explorer John Forrest became the first European to find a route westward from Perth to the Line. The party included two Aboriginal trackers, Kungaitch (Tommy Windich) and Beearragurl (Tommy Pierre). The expedition spent two weeks at the remote desert site of Weld Springs (Palatji), provoking an armed attack by the traditional owners, the Martu people. After six months in the field, Forrest’s party reached the Telegraph Line north of Peake Station on 27 September 1874.
Other explorers relied on the Overland Telegraph Line as well as upon Aboriginal trackers and their bush-craft. William Gosse departed from Alice Springs in April 1873, in direct competition with Warburton’s expedition, but aside from being the first European to see Uluru (naming it Ayers Rock, after the South Australian premier), he was soon forced to retreat to the safety of the Telegraph Line. Gosse drew this sketch of Uluru, reached on 19 July 1873. He wrote in his journal: ‘in its side are large caves, which when viewed from a short distance cause it to present a most remarkable appearance’. (Gosse 1874) It would take another six or seven decades before anthropologists working with Anangu people began to understand the sacred significance of these features, and of the paintings contained in the caves and overhangs of the Rock.
Using the Line: Scientists and Politicians
South Australia took administrative control of the Northern Territory in 1863, assuming that its natural resources could be exploited more effectively once telegraphic communications were established. The Territory was not so easily administered though, and South Australian politicians argued over its economic advantages and disadvantages. In 1891 the South Australian Governor, Lord Kintore, proposed an expedition along the Telegraph Line from Darwin to Adelaide to assess the Territory’s future. Accompanying him was Edward Stirling, director of the South Australian Institute Museum, and police trooper Thomas Cornock. At the telegraph stations Stirling and Cornock were able to barter with visiting Aboriginal men and women for artefacts and natural history specimens.
The Horn Scientific Expedition, 1894
In 1894 a small group of scientists undertook an intensive survey of the MacDonnell Ranges, in Arrernte country. Zoology, anthropology, geology, entomology and ornithology were explored by specialists from Australian museums and universities, travelling through the Ranges by camel. The party based itself at the Alice Springs Telegraph Station, where Francis Gillen and his staff became drawn into the scientific project. By the expedition’s end, Gillen and Baldwin Spencer had become close colleagues. Their collaboration with the Arrernte led to a vastly improved understanding of Aboriginal religion and social structure, the basis for western knowledge of the Dreaming.
Economy of Exchange along the Line
Barter was a key protocol within Aboriginal societies and often marked their frontier dealings with Europeans. The exchange of goods fostered relationships and provided an expectation of reciprocity into the future. The telegraph stations became a source for a range of commodities desired by Aboriginal people, ranging from cloth and metal to tobacco, flour and tea. In exchange, Aboriginal people offered social bonds, and artefacts – boomerangs and other weapons and articles of dress or decoration. Artefact manufacture was a constant process, and these objects were readily replaced; many were even made solely for the exchange. A number of these artefacts are preserved in museums, while little trace remains of the European commodities.
These exchanges seem to have occurred most often in the Central Section of the Overland Telegraph Line where telegraphists such as Gillen, Paddo Byrne at Charlotte Waters, James Field at Tennant Creek or Frank Scott at Barrow Creek collected language vocabularies, engaged Aboriginal women and children to collect particular zoological specimens, documented ethnographic collections with names supplied by Aboriginal people, and supplied specimens to southern museums which now constitute a record of species now rare or extinct in Central Australia.
Another impetus to the trade in objects at the telegraph stations was a letter sent to all the stations along the Overland Telegraph Line by Edward Stirling, Director of the South Australian Museum in 1890. The letter was a call to assemble a record of the culture being gradually extinguished in many parts of the country, helping to activate a network of collectors along the Overland Telegraph Line, so that for the next three decades at least, Aboriginal people actively traded their artefacts for European commodities. The telegraph stations took on a role as distribution centres for rations, and as places where Aboriginal people became increasingly familiar with European ways, the English language, and a range of new commodities. This complex system of reciprocity was extended to the telegraph station staff themselves.
At Alice Springs Telegraph Station, Francis Gillen worked for ten remarkable years in an oddly balanced partnership with Arrernte people. A few months after his arrival he placed the region's senior police officer, Mounted Constable William Willshire, under arrest for murdering two Aboriginal men. Willshire had based his police camp at a waterhole of great ceremonial and economic significance to Arrernte people, known to them as Alitera, located a little east of the Telegraph Line’s route between Charlotte Waters and Alice Springs. For Willshire this was a strategic site for undertaking punitive policing patrols in service to pastoral interests, and for Arrernte Willshire’s name became associated with violent encounters. The anthropologist John Mulvaney also notes that by establishing his police camp at a site of such importance to Arrernte cultural and economic life, Willshire closed off traditional access ‘to its resources and to the route along the Finke gorge’. After Willshire’s arrest, Gillen's standing rose among the Arrernte, who agreed that he and his colleague, W.B. Spencer of the National Museum of Victoria, could witness and document their secret ceremonies. The resulting archive of images and text has become a crucial resource for contemporary Aboriginal people in Central Australia. By the turn of the twentieth century Arrernte ideas, objects, words and images began circulating through metropolitan society in the Australian capitals. Those Arrernte objects also included important natural history specimens and collections of lizards and frogs, insects and mammals.
Aboriginal people bartered many objects to Overland Telegraph workers, particularly during the 1890s, when a network of telegraph station staff were gathering collections on behalf of museums. Some bear the marks of long use; others seem quite freshly made, traded for European commodities. Metal and tobacco were highly desired commodities during this period, worth risking direct contact with Overland Telegraph Line parties or with the repeater stations themselves. Artefacts were readily replaced, particularly as stone became replaced by metal.
Cultural exchange, commodification and conflict along the Line
As well as generating cultural exchange, the Overhead Telegraph triggered conflict. On 22 February 1874, a Kaytetye party attacked the Barrow Creek Telegraph Station, fatally spearing the stationmaster James Stapleton, the linesman John Frank and the station’s Aboriginal employee 'Jemmy'. According to Kaytetye Country, an Aboriginal history of the Barrow Creek area recorded by Grace and Harold Koch, drought and European refusal to share resources with the local Kaytetye people were likely causes of the attack.
Organising a punitive policing party to respond, the South Australian Police Commissioner George Hamilton wrote that the police’s strict ‘adherence to legal forms should not be insisted on’. Without firm action, he said, ‘every telegraph station north of the Peake will be in danger of being at any time attacked’ (South Australian Chronicle, 11 July 1874).
Mounted Constable Samuel Gason led four punitive policing expeditions against the Kaytetye after the Barrow Creek Telegraph Station attack. His official report documented the deaths of 11 Aboriginal people, though other reports suggest that many dozens of people were killed. In Kaytetye oral history recorded by Grace Koch, Gason is still remembered for the retaliatory killing of many people. A gravestone at Barrow Creek Telegraph Station remembers the stationmaster and linesman James Stapleton and John Franks, and another monument in their memory was erected in 1876 by ‘the officers and men on the Overland Telegraph Line’. Not memorialised are the telegraph station’s Aboriginal employee ‘Jemmy’, who was also killed that day, and the many Kaytetye people killed by police parties in retaliation.
In 1901 Francis Gillen met a Kaytetye survivor of the massacre, Tungilla, who became a major source of anthropological data. According to Gillen, Tungilla had been 'implicated' in the 1874 attack on the Barrow Creek station, and only escaped being shot by 'hiding himself in a hole, the mouth of which he closed with a tussock of porcupine [spinifex]'.
Jim Kite Erliakilyika was born in about 1865 near Charlotte Waters, on Lower Southern Arrernte country. He grew up around the telegraph station at Charlotte Waters and worked along the Overland Telegraph Line, travelling as far north as Barrow Creek, where he learnt the Kaytetye language. This background led to his recruitment as one of two guides for Spencer and Gillen's 1901-1902 anthropological expedition which followed the Line from Oodnadatta to Newcastle Waters before heading north-east to Borroloola. Kite and his countryman, Parunda, successfully guided the expedition northwards, managing the horses, camp and cooking duties. Beyond that, Erliakilyika assisted Spencer and Gillen with translating and with interpreting ritual performances. During the expedition he also emerged as a significant frontier artist, filling sketchbooks with figurative drawings of camp life and ethnographic scenes.
On his return to Charlotte Waters he began carving in wood and gypsum, selling small sculptural pieces and intricately carved pipe-bowls to passing travellers. His fame spread and by 1910 he was exhibiting and selling his work in Adelaide.
Labour and governance
By the 1890s a transcultural township had grown around the Alice Springs Telegraph Station, generated by the discovery of gold, the camel trains that followed, and new colonial economies. Arrernte and other Aboriginal people worked within the town and its surrounds, as well as on the camel supply route to Alice Springs.
As well as being active in pastoral station work, Aboriginal women were widely employed as domestic servants at the telegraph stations, including at Alice Springs Telegraph Station as nannies to the stationmaster’s children.
Protectionist legislation (beginning with the Northern Territory Aboriginals Act 1910 and South Australia’s Aborigines Act 1911) imposed stronger forms of government regulation over Aboriginal people’s lives from the early twentieth century. Local police officers often performed double duty as Protectors of Aborigines, and at Alice Springs, the local policeman Protector was Sergeant Robert Stott. In 1914, Ida Standley arrived in Alice Springs to teach the community’s children, and Sergeant Stott provided the Aboriginal rations storeroom as a temporary schoolroom. Initially 25 of Alice Springs’ children, both European and of mixed descent (referred to in the racist language of the time as ‘half-caste’), attended the school, with Mrs Standley assisted by Arabana woman Mrs Topsy Smith. Two of Topsy Smith’s daughters were among the school’s first students.
Protectionist legislation enabled police under the Chief Protector’s direction to remove so-called ‘half-caste’ children from their families and place them under the guardianship of the state. The original school supervised by Ida Standley and Topsy Smith became a training institution, The Bungalow, where children of the Stolen Generations were trained for domestic and agricultural labour. Forced removals of children led to overcrowding at The Bungalow and living conditions grew more inadequate over time. Originally located in an iron building, the Bungalow moved to the old Telegraph Station building in 1932. The Bringing Them Home Report on the Stolen Generations includes the testimony of people who lived at The Bungalow as children and who remember always being hungry. The historian Linda Wells suggests that the Aboriginal children were also likely to retain a sense of cultural community through their carer Topsy Smith, who according to her granddaughter, shared aspects of traditional knowledge with her charges. The Bungalow featured in the Bungalow Song produced for the first Mbantua Festival in 2013 which tells the experience of Stolen Generations children who lived there.
PART FOUR
THE NORTHERN SECTION
The Overland Telegraph Line's northern section passed through a diverse range of Aboriginal country, from the arid lands of the Warumungu and Tjingili north of Tennant Creek to the tropical landscapes of the Larrakia people of the Darwin region. The actual construction of the northern section was completed without any serious clashes, partly because of Todd's strict instruction that Line parties were not to 'fraternise' with Aboriginal people, as a means of minimising the risk of violence. Soon though, as the pattern of displacement and alienation from traditional waters became established, friction increased. Despite this, cultural exchange also occurred.
Port Darwin, in Larrakia country, was a fledging colonial port when the first pole of the Overland was planted there in September 1870. But although it formed a new port of trade and transport for Europeans, the area around Port Darwin was central to centuries-old Larrakia trade with Wagait and Wulna neighbours as well as with people further abroad, particularly the Macassan fishing fleets during their annual voyages to the northern coast to gather trepang (sea-cucumber). These visits had always entailed trade, and often conflict, giving Arnhem Landers confidence in their dealings with these new, European strangers.
A sketch of planting the first pole for the Overland Telegraph Line northern section at Port Darwin for the illustrated press depicts a respectably dressed collection of European settlers gathered to mark the event. Larrakia people are not visible in the picture but they were present. James Stapleton, who would be fatally speared less than four years later in the attack on Barrow Creek Telegraph Station, observed Aboriginal people's reactions to the gun salute that accompanied the erection of the first Overland Telegraph Line pole, noting that it alarmed them.
Paul Foelsche arrived at Port Darwin in 1869, heading the police contingent accompanying the Goyder Survey Expedition. He was present when the Telegraph Line reached Darwin from the Arafura Sea to the north and from the south, and made a remarkable series of portraits of the Larrakia and related groups as they weathered the storm of European contact. In charge of policing on a frontier which was often violent, Foelsche's relations with Aboriginal people were complex, and yet he managed to acquire a remarkable ethnographic collection and his photographic studio, a few metres from the Telegraph Station, was well frequented by Larrakia visitors to Port Darwin. His portraits comprise the fullest record of an Australian Aboriginal group during the first, intense years of contact with Europeans. Foelsche was unusual among frontier collectors in that he made a meticulous record of the Aboriginal names and uses of the objects he collected, together with the names, ages and language groups of his portrait subjects.
Of the three sections of the Overland Telegraph Line, the Northern Section proved to be the most difficult. The logistic challenges of supplying the contractors’ needs by sea, firstly at Port Darwin and later at the Roper River, were greatly compounded by the two Wet seasons of 1871 and 1872, which brought the work to a standstill. Wagon-loads of equipment became bogged or abandoned, and were soon supplying Aboriginal people with a remarkable, unprecedented source of metal. Alfred Giles, a member of the Northern party, noted that an abandoned wagon which he had passed five weeks earlier, in June 1871, ‘nearly new and perfectly sound’, had been stripped of all iron bolts and clamps, ready for conversion into knives, axe blades and spear points.
By 1870 Aboriginal people along the Line’s Northern Section had already become familiar with metal, partly through earlier European and Macassan contact along the northern coast. The supply wagons of the construction parties, as well as the Line itself, now became a new source of supply. The surveyor John Knuckey was able to barter for several axes fashioned from the metal footplates of telegraph poles by Tjingili men near Newcastle Waters. Knuckey passed these axes to Charles Todd himself, in a cycle of reuse and exchange.
The Tennant Creek repeater station was built in Warumungu country, close to the important dreaming site of the Jurnkurakurr waterhole. Warumungu man Dick Cubadgee (Japaljarri) was born in 1870 just before the Overland Telegraph Line was built and he grew up near the new telegraph station. Moving freely between two worlds, he became a guide and cultural broker on European expeditions and participated in colonial exhibitions in the south. But according to Philip Jones, he was equally 'aware of the increasing pressure which European pastoralism imposed upon his people' and he argued before his early death that Europeans should pay with cattle for possession of Warumungu land. Like the other repeater stations, Tennant Creek was a significant point of contact between Europeans and Aboriginal people from its inception.
In 1934, the postmaster at Tennant Creek, George Ashton, wrote to the anthropologist Charles Mountford describing the population growth at Tennant Creek, now a budding gold town. He was responding to Mountford’s request to send Aboriginal drawings of ethnographic interest. Ashton didn't have access to any traditional Aboriginal art, but sent a sketch of the telegraph station by Warumungu senior man Nat Warano Williams. In his history of Tennant Creek, Dean Ashenden writes that Williams worked in the cattle industry and later with the army during the second world war. A nephew of Dick Cubadgee (Japaljarri), he was well known for his skills as a tracker and artist. His works included artefacts he painted for sale to tourists.
PART FIVE
AFTERLIVES OF THE LINE
The Overland Telegraph Line is often remembered, and memorialised, as an engineering achievement. But taking a transcultural view reveals a more complex legacy that reaches right into the present.
The Overland Telegraph Line became a new source of knowledge about Australia's inland, particularly through the agency of telegraph station operators who shared a curiosity about the natural and cultural landscapes surrounding them. Through their observations and collections, often founded on partnerships with Aboriginal people, knowledge of inland geology, natural history, and meteorology expanded rapidly during the late nineteenth century. Aboriginal cultures were documented through anthropology, and Aboriginal languages recorded.
In a 2021 native title case centred on Oodnadatta, Justice White ruled that the effective (British) sovereignty in the area dated from 1872-1873. He based this conclusion on the fact that, rapidly following the establishment of pastoral stations, the construction of the Overland Telegraph Line between 1870 and 1872 had brought hundreds of Europeans to the area. He observed that the track along the Line became the route to Central Australia for pastoralists, explorers, missionaries, police, settlers, teamsters, hawkers, cameleers and travellers. It also facilitated travel by Aboriginal people. Justice White’s judgement recognises the role of the Overland Telegraph Line in the dispossession of those whose lands it traversed.
Inland traffic between Darwin and Adelaide is now serviced by the Stuart Highway, named in memory of the Line’s precursor, John McDouall Stuart. Stuart remains a contested figure.
In 1904, when a large statue of Stuart was unveiled in Adelaide, backed by a map of his route across the continent and the British flag, a crowd of citizens turned out to commemorate his feat of exploration. More than a century later, another statue of Stuart was erected in Alice Springs to mark the 150th anniversary of his successful 1862 expedition. It presents him holding a rife, a reminder of the violence that, in his own journal, Stuart acknowledged as a feature of intruding upon Aboriginal country. During the consultations on constitutional recognition that resulted in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, participants expressed disgust at the erection of this statue. On the importance of truth-telling and the legacy of the past, they said:
This expedition led to the opening up of the ‘South Australian Frontier’ which led to massacres as the telegraph line was established and white settlers moved into the region. People feel sad whenever they see the statue; its presence and the fact that Stuart is holding a gun is disrespectful to the Aboriginal community who are descendants of the families slaughtered during the massacres throughout central Australia.
The collision of cultures along the Overland Telegraph Line is in some places literally written on the landscape. Stuart was drawn to Itirkawarra, a sandstone pillar, and he named it Chambers Pillar after one of his first expedition sponsors. Arrernte Traditional Owners know Itirkawarra to be the Knob-tailed Gecko Man. In 1870, Stuart’s map led members of John Ross’ party to Chambers Pillar during their survey to identify the official route for the Overland Telegraph Line. During this visit John Ross and Alfred Giles, leaders of the party, carved their names into the sandstone, beginning a tradition for many who came after. Initials and dates from explorers and settlers span across centuries. The graffiti disfiguring Itirkawarra is considered irreparable.
The Overland Telegraph Line was essentially redundant by the early 1930s, as Morse Code messaging was superseded by direct telephone communication. By that time, of course, the Stuart Highway was carrying freight and a growing number of travellers in motor cars and trucks. Gradually also, the railway from Adelaide began extending northwards along the Telegraph Line route. It reached Hergott Springs (Marree) in 1884, Oodnadatta in 1891 and Alice Springs in 1929. Finally, in 2004, the rail link was extended to Darwin.
The Overland Telegraph Line had transected the territories of many Aboriginal language groups in South Australia and the Northern Territory, and brought with it irreversible change. Aboriginal people had tended to encounter the worst of European frontier society, although there were some outstanding exceptions. Just over a century after its construction, in 1976, the Northern Territory Land Rights Act was enacted by the Commonwealth Government. For the first time since the Overland Telegraph Line was built, Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory were empowered to define their own countries and to move towards a degree of autonomy. The land rights process often used the Line’s construction as a baseline for the dislocations and loss of land which the Land Rights Act was intended to redress.
A century and a half after the Overland Telegraph Line began operating, how we understand and commemorate the events of the past and their impacts continues to shift and change. The records of conflict, exchange and relationships along the Line contribute to a transcultural history that locates the physical Line within the social worlds it transformed and demonstrates that the impacts of colonisation are ever present. A focus on the transcultural histories of the Line enables us to see more clearly the critical relationship between the past and the present.